Sustainable Bottom Line: 70% of thematic investment fund assets apply no explicit sustainable investing criteria but actively managed funds are more likely to do so.

Notes of Explanation: Notes of Explanation: For mutual funds, share classes are combined. Based on data as of October 31, 2026. Sources: Morningstar and Sustainable Research and Analysis LLC.
Observations:
• Thematic funds, or funds that employ an investment approach with a focus on a particular idea or unifying concept, for example, funds investing in clean energy, water, infrastructure, energy transition and electric vehicles, represent one category of seven approaches that makes up a universe of labeled sustainable mutual funds and ETFs (1). A review based on descriptions set out in fund prospectuses as well as summary prospectuses covering the principal investment strategies of 68 such thematic funds (88 funds and share classes) with $27.4 billion in assets classified by Morningstar as Sector Equity Funds, an aggregate consisting of 12 sub-categories ranging from Utilities to Infrastructure to Alternative Energy (61 funds), Commodities funds (6 funds), and Miscellaneous funds (1 fund) as of October 31, 2026, indicates that many of these funds earn the sustainable label based on their theme rather than from applying sustainable investing criteria (2). While this may satisfy the preferences of many sustainable investors, others might seek to invest in thematic funds that also employ more explicit sustainability criteria. Before investing, such investors will wish to further investigate each fund’s Principal Investment Strategies to gain further insights into each firm’s approach to sustainable investing. Another step that sustainable investors may wish to take is to review stewardship reporting by investment advisers. In an increasing number of cases, stewardship reports indicate that sustainable investment practices are becoming an integrated, mainstream feature of manager’s day-to-day work of balancing risk and return. Investors increasingly understand that sustainability factors can influence investment performance, and therefore need to be tracked, understood and taken into consideration. In the process, this more expansive research can also lead to the expansion of thematic fund options beyond the labeled funds sphere which continues to shrink. Refer to Stewardship Reporting: Largest 50 Asset Management Firms Globally at https://sustainableinvest.com/stewardship-reporting-larger-50-asset-management-firms-globally/
• A review of the Principal Investment Strategies section of prospectuses and summary prospectuses on file for the segment of 68 thematic funds revealed that they could be classified into one of three categories: The first includes funds that apply explicit sustainability or ESG criteria, the second category includes funds that incorporate limited or non-binding sustainability considerations and the third category captures funds that reach investment decisions based on theme only. Refer to Table 1 for a listing of the 68 thematic funds.
• The results indicated that forty-two of the 68 funds (62%), with $19.3 billion or 70% of assets, select securities on thematic exposure alone, typically a revenue threshold plus size and liquidity rules, with no sustainable investing or ESG screens, ratings or exclusions. Only 20 funds (29%), holding 26% of assets, apply explicit criteria, and six more refer to sustainability considerations in limited or non-binding terms. Concentration amplifies the result. First Trust NASDAQ Clean Edge Smart Grid Infrastructure (GRID), at $11.1 billion, accounts for 41% of thematic assets and applies no sustainable investing criteria. Excluding GRID, theme-only funds still hold half of the remaining assets. Among the 15 largest funds, which hold 87% of thematic assets, seven are theme only.
• Ten of 24 actively managed funds (42%) apply explicit criteria and five more apply limited criteria, for a combined 63%. Among 44 index-based funds, only 10 (23%) apply explicit criteria and one more has a limited reference. Weighted by assets, the gap is wider still: 71% of active fund assets are in funds with explicit criteria, versus 16% of index fund assets. Active managers such as Eventide, Fidelity, Impax and KBI build ESG ratings, exclusions or impact assessments directly into security selection. Index funds operate pursuant to whatever rules the index provider sets, and most thematic indexes include none.
• Integration of sustainable investing practices is not limited linked to fund size. About one in four funds in each tier below $500 million applies explicit criteria, versus 56% of the nine funds with $500 million or more; asset-weighted shares are flat at 19% to 26% across tiers.
• Because index funds hold 82% of thematic assets, their approach defines the category. The result is a segment where the sustainable label is largely earned by what a fund owns, clean energy or water companies, rather than by how it evaluates them. Investors who assume a sustainable thematic fund screens for environmental, social and governance risks or practices will usually be wrong unless the fund is actively managed or tracks an index with explicit sustainable investing or ESG rules.
(1) Sustainable investing. While there is no universally accepted framework and definitions continue to evolve, today sustainable investing refers to a range of overarching investment approaches or strategies. That said, many practitioners agree that these approaches encompass at least seven strategies that may be employed individually or in combination. These include values-based investing, negative/positive screening or exclusion strategies, impact investing, thematic investing, ESG integration, shareholder advocacy, issuer engagement and proxy voting, and structural sustainability.
(2) Some thematic funds are tracked under broader investment categories, such as U.S. Equity funds, Internation Equity funds, Taxable Bond funds and Municipal Bond funds. These funds are excluded from this analysis.
Table 1: Listing of thematic funds and their sustainable investing classification
| Fund | Fund Firm | Category | Assets ($M) | Management style | Classification |
| First Trust NASDAQ® Cln Edge®StGidIfsETF | First Trust | Infrastructure | 11,146.6 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Invesco Water Resources ETF | Invesco | Miscellaneous Sector | 2,052.2 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Global Clean Energy ETF | iShares | Alternative Energy | 1,944.5 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| First Trust Water ETF | First Trust | Miscellaneous Sector | 1,830.0 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Eventide Healthcare & Life Sciences | Eventide | Health | 1,603.7 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Invesco Solar ETF | Invesco | Alternative Energy | 872.0 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Fidelity® Climate | Fidelity | Industrials | 640.2 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Victory Global Energy Transition | Victory | Natural Resources | 597.9 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Calvert Global Water | Calvert | Miscellaneous Sector | 536.7 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Vert Global Sustainable Real Estate ETF | Vert | Global Real Estate | 495.4 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| First Trust NASDAQ® Cln Edge® GrnEngyETF | First Trust | Alternative Energy | 468.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Virtus Duff & Phelps Water | Virtus | Miscellaneous Sector | 465.5 | Active | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| Sprott Critical Materials ETF | Sprott | Equity Non-Precious Metals | 418.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Franklin Responsibly Sourced Gold ETF | Franklin | Commodities Focused | 406.1 | Index | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| Global X Atnms & Elctrc Vhcls ETF | Global X | Miscellaneous Sector | 298.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Invesco WilderHill Clean Energy ETF | Invesco | Alternative Energy | 286.7 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Invesco Global Water ETF | Invesco | Miscellaneous Sector | 266.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Redwheel Next Generation Power Infras | Redwheel | Infrastructure | 204.5 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| First Trust Global Wind Energy ETF | First Trust | Alternative Energy | 185.9 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Calvert Global Energy Solutions | Calvert | Alternative Energy | 164.7 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Fidelity Water Sustainability | Fidelity | Miscellaneous Sector | 160.5 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| State Street SPDR S&P KenshoGrdInnvtnETF | SPDR | Alternative Energy | 159.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| GMO Resource Transition VI | GMO | Natural Resources | 152.0 | Active | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| KraneShares Global Carbon ETF | KraneShares | Commodities Focused | 138.2 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Xtrackers Semiconductor Select Eq ETF | Xtrackers | Technology | 129.6 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| VanEck Low Carbon Energy ETF | VanEck | Alternative Energy | 123.8 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| KraneShares California Carbon Allw ETF | KraneShares | Commodities Focused | 120.5 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Self-Driving EV and Tech ETF | iShares | Industrials | 118.0 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Impax Global Sustainable Infras ETF | Impax | Infrastructure | 102.2 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| VanEck Environmental Svcs ETF | VanEck | Industrials | 99.0 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Invesco Global Clean Energy ETF | Invesco | Alternative Energy | 96.5 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Amplify Lithium & Battery Tech ETF | Amplify | Equity Non-Precious Metals | 91.9 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Eventide Exponential Technologies | Eventide | Technology | 88.2 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| ALPS Clean Energy ETF | ALPS | Alternative Energy | 87.0 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Fidelity Clean Energy ETF | Fidelity | Alternative Energy | 83.8 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Global X Hydrogen ETF | Global X | Alternative Energy | 75.9 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| KraneShares Eltc Vhl and Ft Mbly ETF | KraneShares | Industrials | 63.3 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Neuberger Energy Trnstn & Infras ETF | Neuberger | Equity Energy | 57.5 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Energy Storage & Materials ETF | iShares | Miscellaneous Sector | 56.0 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Cromwell Global Infras | Cromwell | Infrastructure | 54.9 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| First Trust S-Network Fut Vhcl&Tech ETF | First Trust | Technology | 42.7 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| KBI Global Investors Aquarius | KBI | Natural Resources | 40.6 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| First Trust EIP Power Solutions ETF | First Trust | Utilities | 35.7 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Goldman Sachs Clean Energy Income | Goldman Sachs | Alternative Energy | 34.9 | Active | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| VanEck Copper and ElectrificationMtlsETF | VanEck | Equity Non-Precious Metals | 30.2 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Strategic Metals ETF | iShares | Commodities Focused | 24.8 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Global X Renewable Energy Producers ETF | Global X | Alternative Energy | 21.9 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Fidelity Elctrc Vhcls & Ftr Trnsptn ETF | Fidelity | Technology | 21.3 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Global X Clean Water ETF | Global X | Miscellaneous Sector | 21.1 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Guinness Atkinson Alternative Energy | Guinness Atkinson | Alternative Energy | 18.7 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Environmentally Aware Rl Est ETF | iShares | Global Real Estate | 13.3 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Principal Global Listed Inf | Principal | Infrastructure | 13.1 | Active | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| iPath® Series B Carbon ETN | iPath | Commodities Focused | 12.8 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Nomura Energy Transition ETF | Nomura | Equity Energy | 12.1 | Active | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| TrueShares Egl Glb Nxt Gn Pwr Infras ETF | TrueShares | Alternative Energy | 11.7 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Firsthand Alternative Energy | Firsthand | Alternative Energy | 11.5 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Guinness Atkinson Smart Trans & Tch ETF | Guinness Atkinson | Technology | 8.7 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| ETFB Green SRI REITs ETF | ETFB | Real Estate | 6.6 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Xtrackers Cybersecurity Select Eq ETF | Xtrackers | Technology | 6.3 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Environmental Infras & IndstrETF | iShares | Infrastructure | 5.6 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| Virtus Duff & Phelps Clean Energy ETF | Virtus | Alternative Energy | 5.0 | Active | Limited or non-binding sustainable investing |
| Invesco Elctc vhcl Mtls Cmd StgyNoK-1ETF | Invesco | Commodities Focused | 4.1 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| iShares Breakthrough Envirtl Sol ETF | iShares | Miscellaneous Sector | 3.5 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
| COtwo Advs Physical Eur Carb AllowanceTr | COtwo | Miscellaneous Sector | 2.0 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| 7RCC Spot Bitcoin And Carb Crdt Futs ETF | 7RCC | Digital Assets | 1.9 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Defiance Autism Impact ETF | Defiance | Health | 1.4 | Index | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Corgi Battery Energy Storage Systems ETF | Corgi | Equity Energy | 0.5 | Active | Theme only – no sustainable investing criteria |
| Xtrackers US Green Infras Sel Eq ETF | Xtrackers | Infrastructure | 0.5 | Index | Explicit sustainable investing criteria |
Notes of Explanation: For mutual funds, share classes are not referenced. Assets data as of October 31, 2026. Sources: Morningstar and Sustainable Research and Analysis LLC.



